在川普政府於6月宣布原始公告後，Lally強烈公開主張藝術品經銷商和收藏家反對提議的關稅。主要的拍賣行也對貿易制裁可能對美國藝術市場造成的潛在經濟損失直言不諱，特別是當收藏家的興趣一直在提升時。在一封給The Art Newspaper的電子郵件中，佳士得聲稱：現在的情勢，對中國藝術品，古董和收藏品課徵關稅可能對美國收藏家，文化機構和企業造成失衡的傷害，並且會無法有效平衡貿易逆差。」
Chinese art and antiquities spared from Trump’s tariffs
Auction houses and art dealers express ‘relief’ even as the US-China trade war escalates
The trade war between the US and China continues to rise in pitch after President Donald Trump announced that a 10% tariff would be imposed on $200bn worth of Chinese goods starting 24 September. US-based art and antiquities dealers, however, are breathing a small sigh of relief. On Monday (17 September), the Office of the United States Trade Representative issued a revised list of imported goods subject to the tariff—which is due to go up to 25% by next year—that no longer includes Chinese-made art and antiquities.
In total, the updated list contains 5,745 full or partial lines of the 6,031 tariff lines that were earlier proposed. The tariff list published on 10 July included Chinese paintings, drawings, pastels, prints, lithographs and original sculptures as well as “antiques of an age exceeding 100 years”. Car seats, bicycle helmets and some consumer electronics products such as smart watches and Bluetooth devices were among the removed items in addition to works of art.
“The free exchange of art is beneficial to all and may provide an avenue toward mutual understanding leading to better relations on other fronts as well,” says James Lally, a New York-based dealer specialising in Chinese art and antiquities. He adds that “it is a great relief to know that [US collectors and dealers] will maintain access to the international market and will be able to freely welcome art lovers from around the world”.
Lally strongly and publicly advocated that art dealers and collectors speak out against the proposed tariffs after the Trump administration’s original announcement was made in June. Major auction houses, too, were outspoken about the potential economic damage the trade sanctions could wreak on the US art market, especially when collector interest has been on the rise. In an email to The Art Newspaper, Christie’s reports that its “position and that of our industry partners continues to be that tariffs on Chinese works of art, antiquities, and collectibles could result in disproportionate harm to American collectors, cultural institutions and businesses and would not be effective in balancing the trade .”
According to the Office of the United States Trade Representative, changes to the proposed list were made after the interagency Section 301 Committee received comments over a six-week period and testimony during a six-day public hearing held in Washington, DC on 23 August. The agency said it “engaged in a thorough process to rigorously examine the comments and testimony and, as a result, determined to fully or partially remove 297 tariff lines from the original proposed list”.
Peter Tompa, a lawyer specialising in the trade of cultural artefacts at the Washington-based firm Bailey & Ehrenberg, argued against Trump’s tariff measures to curtail trade with China at the August hearing, saying they would be more detrimental to US and European dealers than Chinese dealers. He says he is “thankful that USTR and the administration allowed common sense to prevail” in revising the list.
According to data from the US International Trade Commission, imports of antiquities originating from China totalled $107.2m in 2017, while paintings, drawings, pastels and other original works of art totalled $114.5m.
“Tariffs on art would be unprecedented,” Tompa says. “And to impose them here would not only cause collateral damage to American small business and cultural exchange with our allies in the UK, Europe and Asia, especially Japan.” He adds that they would have done “nothing but help promote Chinese government efforts to redirect Chinese art back to China and auction houses linked to its government”.
How long art and antiquities remain safe from Trump’s trade sanctions is still in question. Less than 24 hours after the revised list of goods was revealed, China slapped tariffs on $60bn worth of imports from the US in retaliation. Never one to be challenged, the US president threatened further tariffs on an additional $276bn of goods, which would mean duties on all Chinese imports to the US and amount to around 4% of all world trade.